Moko Kahaan Dundhe Re Bande – Sufism and Bhakti intertwined | Suhayl Abidi

Moko Kahaan Dundhe Re Bande – Sufism and Bhakti intertwined

img1 img2
 Krishna talks with Yudhishthira at Hastinapur
feast Razmnama.
 Rama slays the demon Trishiras. From the
 Ramayana of Akbar’s mother dated 1594 AD.

 

I attended a Sufi festival recently and was pleasantly surprised to find that the first item was a bhajan by member of the tenth generation descendant of Sant Tukaram. This set me thinking (being member of a ‘minority’ community) as to what keeps me safe and secure in India.

There have been many large scale communal conflagrations in the country since independence; the most recent being the Gujarat riots in which over 2000 people died. Though immensely shameful, these riots do not compare anywhere to the genocide in Bosnia where 200,000 were killed, and in the Rwandan genocide between Huti and Tutsi tribes where 800,000 people were killed. Following these instances, fifteen percent of the population in India could be wiped out. Such a thing has not happened despite numerous instances of right wing provocateurs, some of whom even threatened to throw the entire Muslim population in the ocean. Muslims in India, in spite of occasional excesses, feel safer than in neighbouring Pakistan where there is no safety for even the ‘majority’ community, not to say the minorities as Shia Muslims, Hindus and Christians.

Foundation to this phenomenon was laid by the far-sighted Muslim and Hindu sages over seven hundred years back when they found the near simultaneous development of Sufi and Bhakti movements, both liberal incarnations of rigid religious doctrines.

Sufism grew as an offshoot of Islam in the ninth century. Islam’s emphasis on egalitarianism and justice made it acceptable to a large number of people in the Middle East. It spread swiftly and by mid seventh century, it had conquered the entire Middle-East and Persia. Prophet Mohammad’s successors such as Khalifa Umar did not require that non-Muslim populations convert to Islam. Instead, he allowed subject populations to retain their religion, language, customs and government relatively untouched.

By 700 AD, Islamic centre of power had shifted to Damascus, and the Umayyid rulers who brought stability after a long period of civil war.  Later, the Abbasid dynasty laid the foundation of the golden age of Islam with profusion of science, medicine, astronomy, translation of books from Greek and other languages. With the caliph as patron, artists and writers begin to develop a new, partly secular culture based on Islamic ideas.

Khalifah Ma’moon (813 AD) energetically patronised Greek, Sanskrit and Arabic learning and altered the cultural and intellectual face of Islam. It was here that Hellenistic and Indian works made their way into Islamic culture through a series of translations. After Abbasids, Islamic nation fell from a unified cultural and political world into a myriad of independent cultural and political units. This political disintegration of Islamic world saw the rise of the spiritual philosophy of Sufism.

The term Sufi is generally derived from Arabic word Suf (wool), but it is probably a corruption of the Greek ‘sophos’ (wise). Many view that it derives from the words safa (purity), saf (row), or from ashab-i-safa (row of holy persons). Whatever its etymology, tasawwuf or Sufism essentially means “spiritual meditation for the purification of the immortal soul.”

Sufism is Islam’s tolerant, mystical and universal philosophy. It closely resembles other mystical movements such as Kabbalah, Christian mysticism, Yoga, Vedanta, or Zen.  Its message of sulh-i-kul (peace with all) has endeared both Muslims and non-Muslims alike. It appeals to all Muslim sects and social classes, though its origin is unimpeachable, tracing back to the Prophet himself. The Sufi must first master the Shar’iah, the true path of Islam, before venturing onto the tariqah, the Sufi way.

Not Christian or Jew or Muslim,
not Hindu, Buddhist, Sufi or Zen.
Not any religion, or cultural system.
I am not from the East or the West,
nor out of the ocean or up
from the ground, not natural or ethereal,
not composed of elements at all.
I do not exist, am not an entity in this world
or the next,
did not descend from Adam and Eve
or any origin story.
My place is placeless, a trace of the traceless.
Neither body nor soul.
I belong to the beloved
have seen the two worlds as one
and that one call to and know,
First, last, outer, inner, only that
breath breathing human.

(An excerpt from the Coleman Barks’ translations of Jalaluddin Rumi’s ‘Only Breath’)

Divine worship, devotion to God, aversion from the world, abstinence from wealth, retirement into solitude for worship are essential characteristics of Sufis.

In general, the Sufis have looked upon themselves as those Muslims who take seriously God’s call to perceive His presence, both in the world and in the self. They stress inwardness over outwardness, contemplation over action, spiritual development over legalism, and cultivation of the soul over social interaction. On the theological level, Sufis speak of God’s mercy, gentleness and beauty far more than they discuss His wrath, severity, and majesty. In a broad sense, Sufism can be described as the internalisation and intensification of Islamic faith and practice.

Those who don’t feel this Love
pulling them like a river,
those who don’t drink dawn
like a cup of spring water
or take in sunset like supper,
those who don’t want to change,
let them sleep.

(By Rumi)

Islam spread from Arabia to Turkey and Iran where civilisations were hundreds of years old and had established religions and culture. Sufis interpreted Islam which was palatable to the non-believers, and for the first time demonstrated how two religions and cultures co-exist. By the time Islam came to India in the 11th century, Sufism was developed in the Middle-East and had a large number of teachers or ‘masters’ who travelled throughout the Islamic world spreading their faith of love and tolerance. Once again, in India, Islam came in touch with an older religion – Hinduism. Sufism showed the rulers and Muslims how to peacefully co-exist with the Hindu brethren.

The Sufis of the Chishti order, the predominant Sufi order in India have tried to relate to the Indian culture and music. They experimented and enriched various cultural forms. Some Sufis under the Chishtiyya order were not against absorbing ideas from the Hindu Bhakti movement and even used Hindi for their devotional songs. However, the orthodox Ulema with royal support insisted that the Sufis go ‘back to Shariat.’ It is believed that the Sufis may have begun the celebration of Basant amongst Indian Muslims as early as 12th century and they may have sung in Persian.

Ashkrezaamadastabr-e-bahaar

Saaqiagulbarez-o-baadabeyaar

Or, Arab yaar tori Basantmanayi

 Sakal bun (or Saghanbhun) phoolrahisarson,
Sakal bun phoolrahi…..
Umbvaphutay, tesuphulay, koyalbolaydaardaar,
Aurgori karat singaar,
Malaniyangadhwa lay aayinkarson,
Sakal bun phoolrahi…..
Tarahtarahkayphoollagaaye,
Lay gadhwahaathanmeinaaye.
Nijamudinkaydarwazay par,
Aawankehgayeaashaq rung,
Aur beet gayebarson.
Sakal bun phoolrahisarson.
 
The yellow mustard is blooming in every field,
Mango buds are clicking open, other flowers too;
The koyel chirps from branch to branch,
And the maiden tries her make-up,
The gardener-girls have brought bouquets.
Colourful flowers of all kinds,
In hands everyone’s bringing;
But Aashiq-rung (the lover), who had promised to come
To Nizamuddin’s house in spring,
Hasn’t turned up – its been years.
The yellow mustard is blooming in every field.

 

They revived Basant by bringing sarson (mustard) flowers and saffron chadars to the dargahs. The great poet, Amir Khusro has written hundreds of Holigeets to his Guru, whom he compares to Krishna: Mohesuhagan, rang basanti rang de Khwajaji/ Aao, Sufiion sang Holikhelo.

Sufis have a long tradition of adapting to local culture and language to spread their message. The development of Qawalli was a major introduction to spread the word of Sufism in the musical minded India population. Chishtis successfully adapted themselves to the Indian conditions and local environment, both physical and social.

Sufism got a boost during the reign of Emperor Akbar, who propagated the new religion Din-e-Ilahi that did not distinguish between faiths. Starting with Akbar, Mughal rulers got Indian epics translated into Persian for greater understanding of Hindu scriptures. A Brahmin named Debi is known to have instructed him in the philosophy of Hinduism. Ramayana itself has twenty eight known translations and the one magnificently illustrated version commissioned on the orders of Akbar’s mother Hamida Banu Begum is presently in the collection of the Jaipur royal family. It shows the deep interest of not only the emperors, but their family members in Hindu epics.

At the same time, Bhakti movement started taking roots in India rebelling against the strict BrahminicalcCode, especially the condemnation of caste system. Like the Sufis, Bhakti saints such as Tukaram preached the unity of God, love for mankind, religious tolerance and importance of good deeds. Gradually, Sufism and the Bhakti cult became popular and created an atmosphere of mutual trust and peaceful coexistence between Hindus and the Muslims.

All men to me are god-like Gods!
My eyes no longer see vice or fault.

Life on this suffering earth
is now endless delight;
the heart at rest, full, overflowing.

In the mirror, the face and its reflection -
they watch each other; different, but one.

And, when the stream pours into the ocean… no more stream!

According to one legend, Lord Ram blessed Prince Dara Shikoh, eldest son of Shahjahan in a dream to translate the Bhagavad Gita into Persian. Bhagavad Gita reached the west and India’s Vedic history was rediscovered. Dara Shikoh was a great Sanskrit scholar and was loved by the Pundits of Kashi, the Sikh Gurus and the Sufis alike. He was murdered by his youngest brother Aurangzeb.

Goswami Tulsidas, the great devotee of Lord Ram wrote the Ramayana under protection of the Mughal Governor of Banaras and his best friend, Abdul Rahim Khankhana, (the great Krishnabhakt, famous for Rahim Kedohe). Goswami Tulsidas was harassed by the powerful Brahmin priests, who did not want him to compose the Ramayana in Jan-bani, but Sanskrit.

The Nawabs of Awadh used to spend thirteen days in celebrating Holi.Wajid Ali Shah’s court played Raslila for Lord Krishna. The most famous Hindu dharmic play, Indra abha was composed in his court by a Muslim writer.

Guru Nanak was a great saint of the Bhakti movement. He preached universal brotherhood, unity of God and religious tolerance. He also condemned caste distinction, idol worship and meaningless rituals. The foundation of the Golden temple was laid by a Muslim Sufi – Hazrat Mian Mir, a close companion of Guru Arjun Dev. He was also the teacher of Dara Shikoh, whose life the Sikh Guru, had saved as a child due to his great love for him.

That Guru Nanak’s lifelong companion was Mian Mardana, a Muslim rabab player. He is the first singer of Sikh gurbani and his descendants played the rabab in the Golden temple for 500 years till 1947.

Just like Turkish pilaf met Indian spices to create biryani, it was inevitable that Sufi and Bhakti movements too would converge. Sant Kabir and Guru Nanak are the finest examples of this convergence. Sant Kabir is believed to have breathed his last at the town of Maghar in UP. Hindus and Muslims fought over how his last rites should be performed. The legend goes – the body miraculously vanished with flowers taking its place. The Muslims took the sheet that had covered the body, the Hindus took the flowers. Today, the shrine at Kabir Nirvana Sthal, where people of both religions pay tribute, includes a mausoleum built by Hindus and a tomb by Muslims.

मोकोकहाँढूंढेरेबन्दे मैंतोतेरेपासमें नातीरथमें , नामूरतमें नाएकांतनिवासमें नामन्दिरमें , नामस्जिदमें नाकाबेकैलासमें मैंतोतेरेपासमें बन्देमैंतोतेरेपासमें नामैंजपमें , नामैंतपमें नामेंबरतउपासमें नामैंकिरियाकरममें रहतानहींजोगसन्यासमें नहींप्राणमेंनहींपिंडमें नाब्रह्माण्डअकासमें नामेंप्रकुतिप्रवरगुफामें नहींस्वसनकीस्वांसमें खोजीहोएतुरतमिलजाऊं इकपलकीतलासमें कहतकबीरसुनोभाईसाधो मेंतोहूँविस्वासमें MokoKahanDhundhere BandeMein To TerePaas MeinNa Teerath Mein, Na Moorat MeinNa EkantNiwas MeinNa Mandir Mein, Na Masjid MeinNa Kabe Kailas Mein Main To TerePaas Mein Bande Mein To TerePaas Mein Na Main Jap Mein, Na Main Tap Mein Na Mein Barat Upaas Mein Na Main KiriyaKarm Mein Rehta Nahin Jog Sanyas Mein NahinPran Mein NahinPind Mein Na Brahmand Akas Mein Na Mein PrakutiPrawarGufa Mein NahinSwasan Ki Swans Mein KhojiHoyeTurat Mil Jaoon Ik Pal Ki Talas Mein KahatKabirSunoBhaiSadho Mein To Hun Viswas Mein Where do you search me? I am with you Not in pilgrimage, nor in icons Neither in solitudes Not in temples, nor in mosques Neither in Kaba nor in Kailash I am with you o man I am with you Not in prayers, nor in meditation Neither in fasting Not in yogic exercises Neither in renunciation Neither in the vital force nor in the body Not even in the ethereal space Neither in the womb of Nature Not in the breath of the breath Seek earnestly and discover In but a moment of searchSays Kabir, Listen with care Where your faith is, I am there.

While the Brahmins and the Islamic theologians wrote in Sanskrit and Arabic, the Sufis and Bhakti saints wrote in their local languages. This helped in developing regional languages such as Hindi, Gujarati, Marathi and Bengali. In short, the Sufi and the Bhakti movements helped to establish communal harmony and lay the foundation of a composite Indian culture which was the synthesis of what was valuable from both Hindu and Islamic cultures.

Today, the strength of this intermingling of faith can be seen in thousands of samadhis and Dargahs throughout the country where both Hindus and Muslims continue to visit in large numbers, such as Ajmer Dargahand, Bababudangiri shrine in Karnataka for spiritual sustenance.

The Sufi festival ended with a qawwali. As long as bhajans and qawallis continue to enlighten us in the same festival, I can sleep with ease despite the occasional humdrums by Togadia and Owaisi.

Views expressed here are the writer’s own.

(The views expressed in this column are the writer’s own)

Please Note: Tehelka doesn't have regulatory control over messages appearing on social media including Facebook and Twitter. Tehelka also doesn't subscribe to any views or comments by the readers.


  • http://Website sheik abdul taher

    REALITY OF SUFISM
    Sufism is known as “Islamic Mysticism,” in which Muslims seek to find divine love and knowledge through direct personal experience of God. Mysticism is defined as the experience of mystical union or direct communion with ultimate reality, and the belief that direct knowledge of God, spiritual truth, or ultimate reality can be attained through subjective experience (as intuition or insight). Both the terms Sufi and Sufism and Sufi beliefs have no basis from the traditional Islamic sources of the Qur’an and Sunnah (the sayings and religious approvals of Prophet Mohammed (Peace be upon him), a fact even admitted by Sufiis.

    Sufism is in essence a conglomerate consisting of extracts from a multitude of other religions with which Sufi’s interacted. During the primary stages of Sufism, Sufis were characterised by their particular attachment to zikr (remembrance of Allah) and asceticism (seclusion), as well as the beginning of innovated practices to ‘aid’ in the religious practices. Yet even at the early stage of Sufism, before their involvement in innovated rituals and structured orders, the scholars warned the masses of the extremity of Sufi practices.

    Imam Al-Shafi’ had the opinion that “If a person exercised Sufism (Tasawafa) at the beginning of the day, he doesn’t come at Zuhur except an idiot”. Imam Malik and Ahmad bin Hanbal also shared similar ideas on this new movement which emanated from Basrah, Iraq. Although it began as a move towards excessive Ibaadah, such practices were doomed to lead to corruption, since their basis did not come from authentic religious doctrines, but rather from exaggerated human emotions.

    Sufism as an organised movement arose among pious Muslims as a reaction against the worldliness of the early Umayyad period (AD 661-750). In the chaotic state of affairs that existed during the fifth and sixth centuries A.H. Sufiis invited people to follow their way, alleging that the remedy to this chaos was conformity to the guidance of their order’s Sheikhs. Dar al-Hikmah was established during the reign of Khalifah Ma’moon, where he invited the scholars of the Romans and Greeks to meet with the Muslims and ‘discuss’ their respective positions. This provided the perfect ground for the synthesis between Islamic and other theology, to produce the Sufism of the like of Ibn Arabi.

    The Mixing Pot
    With the demise of the Companions of the Prophet and their successors, the door became open for the distortion of Islamic Principles. Forgeries of hadith (Prophet and subsequently created new sects such as the Khawaarij and Mu’tazilah. Sufism gained its breeding ground during this period, whereby it gained its support from the Dynastic Rulers, who had deviated from Islam to the extent whereby magic was used as entertainment in their courts, even though magic is considered as Kufr in Islam. During this period, Sufism developed its Shi’a flavour, indeed the roots of contemporary Sufism have been traced back to Shi’a origins . Sufi ideology and thinking flourished during the times of the likes of Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi, Jalal Ad Din Rumi, and Imam Ghazali. Their translation of Greek philosophical works into Arabic during the third Islamic century left an indelible mark on many aspects of Sufism, resulting in Greek pantheism becoming an integral part of Sufi doctrine. Pagan practices such as Saint worshipping, the use of magic and holding venerance towards their Sheikh overtook the Orthodox practices of Islam and had little resemblance to the Islam left by our Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alaihi wa sallam). By examining the mystic doctrines of Christianity, Hinduism, Taoism and other religions, it becomes clear how closer Sufism is to these religions than to Islam. In fact, Sufism is never characterised under “Islam” in any system of catalogue, but rather under ‘Mysticism’. Sharda highlights these unsurprising similarities by stating that: “After the fall of Muslim orthodoxy from power at the centre of India for about a century, due to the invasion of Timur, the Sufi became free from the control of the Muslim orthodoxy and consorted with Hindu saints, who influenced them to an amazing extent. The Sufi adopted Monism and wifely devotion from the Vaishnava Vedantic school and Bhakti and Yogic practices from the Vaishnava Vedantic school. By that time, the popularity of the Vedantic pantheism among the Sufis had reached its zenith.”
    In short a Muslim believes in the Uniqueness of God. He has no partner; no one is like unto Him. God, Almighty, says:
    “There is nothing like unto Him and He is the all-Hearing and the all-Seeing.” (Quran 42:11)
    God is separate from His creation and not a part of it. He is the Creator, and all else is His creation.
    Sufis hold a number of beliefs in relation to God, Almighty; of these be-liefs are the following:
    a) Al-Hulool: This belief denotes that God, Almighty, dwells in His creation.
    b) Al-It’tihaad: This belief denotes that God, Almighty, and the creation are one, united presence.
    c) Wahdatul-Wujood: This belief denotes that one should not differen-tiate between the Creator and the creation, for both the creation and the Creator are one entity.

    Reality of sufism……. mired by saints, pir, murid . The Sheikh or Wali is given a similar standing as that of a Catholic Saint, or the Dalai Lama himself. Complete obedience is enforced on his followers, and any questions are deemed as a betrayal of trust: “The seeker must submit to the will of the Sheikh and to obey him in all his orders and advice, because the Sheikh has more experience and more knowledge in Haqiqat, in Tariqat and in Shari’ah,” and “he must agree with the opinion of his Sheikh completely, as the patient agrees with the physician”. Yet Muslims believe that any single act of worship must be substantiated by the Qur’an and Sunnah only. Allah the Exalted says: “Say (to them), ‘Produce your proof if you are truthful’.” [2: 111], and the Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alaihi wa sallam) said “The created is not to be obeyed over the Creator.” The Sheikh is given the standing of a deity in Sufism. Attributes which belong to Allah, are also assigned to their Sheikhs. They seek help from them, whether they are dead or 10,000km away. They believe that their sheikhs know everything their students are thinking, and that they converse with the Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alaihi wa sallam) on a regular basis (in reality).

    Sufi tareeqahs and the ruling on joining them.
    In the sufis thariqa’ there was a term call syari’a,thariqa’,haqiqa’ and ma’rifah.Is this term really have been tought by Prophet Muhammad (pbuh)to his companion according to the definition by the thariqa’ it self.
    Praise be to Allaah.
    We must understand that the word al-soofiyyah (Sufism) refers to wearing woollen clothes [the Arabic word soof means “wool”] and nothing else.
    Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (may Allaah have mercy on him) said:
    The word al-soofiyyah (Sufism) refers to wearing woollen clothes; this is the correct meaning. It was said that it comes from the word safwat al-fuqaha’ (the elite of the fuqaha’) or from Soofah ibn Add ibn Taanijah, an Arab tribe that was known for its asceticism, or from Ahl al-Suffah (poor Muslims in Madeenah at the time of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) who used to stay in the mosque), or from al-Safa (the mountain in Makkah), or from the word al-safwah (meaning elite), or from the phrase al-saff al-muqaddam bayna yaday Allaah (the foremost rank before Allaah). All of these views are weak (da’eef); if any of them were true then the word would be saffi or safaa’i or safawi, not sufi.
    Majmoo’ al-Fataawa, 11/195
    Sufism (tasawwuf) did not appear until after the first three generations which the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) praised when he said, “The best of mankind is my generation, then those who come after them, then those who come after them…” (narrated by al-Bukhaari, 2652; Muslim, 2533; from the hadeeth of Ibn Mas’ood).
    Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (may Allaah have mercy on him) said:
    With regard to the word soofiyyah (Sufism), it was not known during the first three generations, rather it became known after that.
    Majmoo’ al-Fataawa, 11/5
    This tareeqah and its like are among the innovated ways that go against the Qur’aan and Sunnah and the way followed by the best generations. All the shaykhs of these tareeqahs have made up their own wirds (phrases to be uttered as dhikr), hizb (books of du’aa’ to be read daily by their followers) and ways of worship by which each of them may be distinguished from the others; this goes against sharee’ah and divides the ummah.
    Allaah has blessed this ummah by perfecting its religion and completing His Favour upon it, so everyone who comes up with an act of worship or a way that was not brought by sharee’ah is effectively rejecting what Allaah has said and accusing the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) of betraying the trust.
    Along with this innovation of theirs, they may also be lying by claiming that they received their tareeqah from the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him), or that they are following the path and guidance of the Rightly-Guided Caliphs (al-khulafa’ al-raashideen).
    The scholars of the Standing Committee were asked:
    Is there any such thing in Islam as the numerous tareeqahs like the Shaadhilyyah, Khalwatiyyah etc? If there is such a thing, what is the evidence for that? What is the meaning of the verses in which Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning):
    “And verily, this is My straight path, so follow it, and follow not (other) paths, for they will separate you away from His path. This He has ordained for you that you may become Al Muttaqoon (the pious)”
    [al-An’aam 6:153]
    “And upon Allaah is the responsibility to explain the Straight Path. But there are ways that turn aside (such as Paganism, Judaism, Christianity). And had He willed, He would have guided you all (mankind)”
    [al-Nahl 16:9]
    What are the ways that separate people from the path of Allaah, and what is the way of Allaah? What is the meaning of the hadeeth narrated by Ibn Mas’ood, according to which the Messenger (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) drew a line and said, “This is the path of guidance,” then he drew lines to its right and another to its left and said, “These are other paths and on each path there is a devil calling people to it”?
    They answered:
    There is no such thing in Islam as the tareeqahs that you mentioned, or anything else like them. What there is in Islam is what is indicated by the two verses and the hadeeth that you quoted, and what was indicated by the hadeeth in which the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “The Jews split into seventy-one sects, and the Christians split into seventy-two sects. My ummah will split into seventy-three sects, all of which will be in Hell except one.” It was asked, “Who are they, O Messenger of Allaah?” He said, “Those who follow the same path as I and my companions are on today.” And he (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said, “A group among my ummah will continue to follow the truth and to be victorious, and they will not be harmed by those who forsake them or oppose them, until the command of Allaah comes to pass when they are like that.” The truth lies in following the Qur’aan and the saheeh, unambiguous Sunnah of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him). This is the path of Allaah, this is the Straight Path. This is the straight line mentioned in the hadeeth of Ibn Mas’ood, and this is what was followed by the companions of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) (may Allaah be pleased with them and with their followers among the early generations (salaf) of this ummah, and with those who follow their path). All other tareeqahs or groups are the paths mentioned in the verse (interpretation of the meaning):
    “… and follow not (other) paths, for they will separate you away from His path…”
    [al-An’aam 6:153]
    Fataawa al-Lajnah al-Daa’imah, 2/283, 284
    And Allaah knows best.
    Islam Q&A

    • http://Website Suhayl Abidi

      My attempt was only to show that Sufis had a pivotal role to play in creating conditions for peaceful hindu muslim co-existence in India for last 700 years. Sufism is a controversial topic and people have strong opinions depending on which side of the religious spectrum they belong to. This blog was not a treatise on Sufism.

  • http://Website Rana Safvi

    Very well written article. Thank you for highlighting India’s unique ganga-jamuni tahzeeeb
    As Bulleh Shah wrote:

    If the divine is found through ablutions
    surely frogs and fish would find him first
    if the divine is hidden in jungles
    the cattle would have discovered him by now
    O Bulleh, the divine is found by those
    with pure and true heart”

  • http://www.chhayap nisha

    This is the beauty of our culture and fluidity of dreams are a part of this beauty; dreams are a delicate tool that transgresses the barriers raised by the fundamentalists, misogynists & proponents of caste based hierarchy.

  • http://Website Sumaira

    Beautifully written! When can we expect some more thoughts?